| Round 12 | |||
| Pick | Team | Player | |
| 265. | Pendleton BUCS | Bielak,Brandon | |
| 266. | Chicago Orphans | Haniger,Mitch | |
| 267. | Delmarva Shorebirds (via trade w/ St. George Island Waveriders) | Newman,Kevin | |
| 268. | San Diego Americanos | Crochet,Garrett | |
| 269. | Fenway's Frank's | Moore,Dylan | |
| 270. | Swinging Donkeys | McCarthy,Jake | |
| 271. | Memphis Hound Dogs | Margot,Manuel | |
| 272. | Seattle Rainers | Peterson,David | |
| 273. | Los Angeles Sluggers | Laureano,Ramon | |
| 274. | Fitchburg Mad Bombers | Rojas,Miguel | |
| 275. | La Jolla Mastiffs | Jankowski,Travis | |
| 276. | CLINTON GRAYS | Keller,Brad | |
| 277. | South Jersey Bulldogs | Henry,Tommy | |
| 278. | Cuyahoga LumberKings | Renfroe,Hunter | |
| 279. | Long Island Ducks | Sims,Lucas | |
| 280. | Miami Beach Manatees | Kelly,Joe | |
| 281. | Durham Lollygaggers | Massey,Michael | |
| 282. | Houston Roughnecks | Teheran,Julio | |
| 283. | Wicker Park Wildcats | d'Arnaud,Travis | |
| 284. | Steel Plains Thunder | Kemp,Tony | |
| 285. | Kansas City Phenoms | Higashioka,Kyle | |
| 286. | Delmarva Shorebirds | Brash,Matt | |
| 287. | London Silly Nannies | Anderson,Nick | |
| 288. | Green Bay Blizzard | Speier,Gabe | |
| Round 13 | |||
| Pick | Team | Player | |
| 289. | Pendleton BUCS | Wood,Alex | |
| 290. | Chicago Orphans | Ortiz,Luis L. | |
| 291. | St. George Island Waveriders | Schmitt,Casey | |
| 292. | San Diego Americanos | Garcia,Avisail | |
| 293. | Fenway's Frank's | Rodgers,Brendan | |
| 294. | Swinging Donkeys | Wilson,Steven | |
| 295. | Memphis Hound Dogs | Boyle,Joe | |
| 296. | Seattle Rainers | Refsnyder,Rob | |
| 297. | Los Angeles Sluggers | Tonkin,Michael | |
| 298. | Fitchburg Mad Bombers | Frazier,Adam | |
| 299. | La Jolla Mastiffs | McGuire,Reese | |
| 300. | CLINTON GRAYS | Lynch,Daniel | |
| 301. | South Jersey Bulldogs | Caratini,Victor | |
| 302. | Cuyahoga LumberKings | Lange,Alex | |
| 303. | Long Island Ducks | Trevino,Jose | |
| 304. | Miami Beach Manatees | Soto,Gregory | |
| 305. | Durham Lollygaggers | Butler,Lawrence | |
| 306. | Houston Roughnecks | Merryweather,Julian | |
| 307. | Wicker Park Wildcats | Stewart,Brock | |
| 308. | Steel Plains Thunder | Raley,Brooks | |
| 309. | Kansas City Phenoms | Smyly,Drew | |
| 310. | Delmarva Shorebirds | Rivas,Alfonso | |
| 311. | London Silly Nannies | Ryu,Hyun Jin | |
| 312. | Green Bay Blizzard | Velasquez,Vince | |
| Round 14 | |||
| Pick | Team | Player | |
| 313. | Pendleton BUCS | Yepez,Juan | |
| 314. | Chicago Orphans | Weathers,Ryan | |
| 315. | St. George Island Waveriders | Soriano,Jose | |
| 316. | Green Bay Blizzard (via trade w/ San Diego Americanos) | Robles,Victor | |
| 317. | Fenway's Frank's | Junis,Jakob | |
| 318. | Swinging Donkeys | Meyers,Jake | |
| 319. | Memphis Hound Dogs | Irvin,Cole | |
| 320. | Seattle Rainers | Rogers,Taylor | |
| 321. | Los Angeles Sluggers | Jimenez,Joe | |
| 322. | Fitchburg Mad Bombers | Urias,Ramon | |
| 323. | La Jolla Mastiffs | Vargas,Ildemaro | |
| 324. | CLINTON GRAYS | Patino,Luis | |
| 325. | South Jersey Bulldogs | Madrigal,Nick | |
| 326. | Cuyahoga LumberKings | Thaiss,Matt | |
| 327. | Long Island Ducks | Ramirez,Nick | |
| 328. | Miami Beach Manatees | Maile,Luke | |
| 329. | Durham Lollygaggers | Bleday,JJ | |
| 330. | Houston Roughnecks | Peguero,Elvis | |
| 331. | Wicker Park Wildcats | Walls,Taylor | |
| 332. | Steel Plains Thunder | Pinto,Rene | |
| 333. | Kansas City Phenoms | Loftin,Nick | |
| 334. | Delmarva Shorebirds | Hudson,Dakota | |
| 335. | London Silly Nannies | Butto,Jose | |
| 336. | Green Bay Blizzard | Jackson,Jay | |
| Round 15 | |||
| Pick | Team | Player | |
| 337. | Pendleton BUCS | Waldichuk,Ken | |
| 338. | Chicago Orphans | White,Owen | |
| 339. | St. George Island Waveriders | Montero,Elehuris | |
| 340. | South Jersey Bulldogs (via trade w/ San Diego Americanos) | Gibaut,Ian | |
| 341. | Fenway's Frank's | Syndergaard,Noah | |
| 342. | Swinging Donkeys | Allen,Nick | |
| 343. | Memphis Hound Dogs | Trejo,Alan | |
| 344. | Seattle Rainers | Marsh,Alec | |
| 345. | Los Angeles Sluggers | Smith,Dominic | |
| 346. | Fitchburg Mad Bombers | Padlo,Kevin | |
| 347. | La Jolla Mastiffs | Chirinos,Yonny | |
| 348. | CLINTON GRAYS | Small,Ethan | |
| 349. | South Jersey Bulldogs | Rivera,Emmanuel | |
| 350. | Cuyahoga LumberKings | Kerkering,Orion | |
| 351. | Long Island Ducks | Call,Alex | |
| 352. | Miami Beach Manatees | Joyce,Ben | |
| 353. | Durham Lollygaggers | May,Trevor | |
| 354. | Houston Roughnecks | Fry,David | |
| 355. | Wicker Park Wildcats | Stripling,Ross | |
| 356. | Steel Plains Thunder | Barlow,Scott | |
| 357. | Kansas City Phenoms | Corbin,Patrick | |
| 358. | Delmarva Shorebirds | Bouchard,Sean | |
| 359. | CLINTON GRAYS (via trade w/ London Silly Nannies) | Kowar,Jackson | |
| 360. | Green Bay Blizzard | Garcia,Robert | |
| Round 18 | |||
| Pick | Team | Player | |
| 409. | Pendleton BUCS | Wentz,Joey | |
| 410. | Chicago Orphans | Gonzales,Nick | |
| 411. | St. George Island Waveriders | Bradford,Cody | |
| 412. | San Diego Americanos | Turnbull,Spencer | |
| 413. | Fenway's Frank's | Garcia,Yimi | |
| 414. | Swinging Donkeys | Burke,Brock | |
| 415. | Memphis Hound Dogs | Walker,Ryan | |
| 416. | Seattle Rainers | Mejia,Francisco | |
| 417. | Los Angeles Sluggers | Brujan,Vidal | |
| 418. | Fitchburg Mad Bombers | Holderman,Colin | |
| 419. | La Jolla Mastiffs | Stephan,Trevor | |
| 420. | CLINTON GRAYS | Hill,Rich | |
| 421. | South Jersey Bulldogs | Gomber,Austin | |
| 422. | Cuyahoga LumberKings | Votto,Joey | |
| 423. | Long Island Ducks | DeJong,Paul | |
| 424. | Miami Beach Manatees | Remillard,Zach | |
| 425. | Durham Lollygaggers | Plesac,Zach | |
| 426. | Houston Roughnecks | Perez,Carlos | |
| 427. | Wicker Park Wildcats | Paddack,Chris | |
| 428. | Steel Plains Thunder | Chavez,Jesse | |
| 429. | Kansas City Phenoms | Middleton,Keynan | |
| 430. | Delmarva Shorebirds | Kelly,Carson | |
| 431. | London Silly Nannies | Karinchak,James | |
| 432. | Green Bay Blizzard | Martini,Nick | |